Everyday masculinities in 21st-century China:
the making of able-responsible men
Hong Kong University Press (2020)
This book provides an emic account of how people conceptualize masculinity in China, and how it affects men’s lives and their relationships.
I draw on the concept of hegemonic masculinity made known by sociologist Raewyn Connell. According to Connell, hegemonic masculinity is a cultural ideal that legitimizes and naturalizes the interests of powerful men, and which creates hierarchical relationships between men and between the two genders.
The type of hegemonic masculinity that I argue has gained growing significance in China is the “able-responsible men”. This masculine ideal is defined by a combination of ability (nengli) and responsibility (zeren).
Most scholars who consider gender-related topics in China since the late 1980s have suggested a desired form of manhood that is coupled with wealth. The earlier reform-and-opening-up era in China has led to this rise of a ‘moneyed elite’ as the dominant male ideal. I argue in my book that even though financial power remains a critical factor defining masculinity, it has become a necessary but not sufficient condition for a man of honour; an equally important dimension is responsibility.
Material wealth, such as properties and cars, is a visible sign of a man’s ability. A more subtle, but fertile, ground for demonstrating ability is how a man uses his time. Leisure, entertainment, and engagements in large and small investment projects, are important too. These all point to one’s consumption power. Apart from this, there was a growing discourse in China on the cultivation of responsibility and self-discipline in society. This leads to a second dimension in defining manhood – responsibility as a son, father, husband, son-in-law, kinsman, and a national subject.
Book Reviews
‘In this richly informative book, Dr Wong gives us an intimate picture of masculinities in a contemporary Chinese city. She explores the role of wealth in definitions of masculinity, the moral dimension in gender imagery, the changing desires of women, and the role of the state ––including a striking account of the gender strategies of President Xi. More than a local study, this book provides valuable ideas for understanding gender, men, and masculinities in the contemporary world.’
—Raewyn Connell, University of Sydney
‘Magdalena Wong asks wonderful, original questions. Her study might be one of the most pioneering investigations into Chinese family relations I have read. The strength of her book lies in its insight into kinship and cultural continuities and changes. The rich, nuanced case studies can make her book become an important addition to our ongoing studies on Chinese family.’
—William Jankowiak, University of Nevada, Las Vegas
‘Despite its caveats discussed in depth, Wong considers the able-responsible man model essentially benevolent. Wong partly attributes this positivity to women’s role in shaping the ideal that benefits them because of its emphasis on men’s family responsibility. This positive take might generate debate among scholars of hegemonic masculinity.... Regardless, Everyday Masculinities is an important work to be read by researchers interested in families and gender relations in contemporary China. Given its high readability, it is also appropriate for undergraduate courses on family and gender in anthropology, sociology, and Asian studies.’
—Hiromi Taniguchi, University of Louisville
Harmony ideology in Chinese families:
Cooperating despite unfairness
Book article in Cooperation in Chinese communities: Morality and practice
Bloomsbury Academic (2019)
This chapter situates cooperation in the domain of kinship and reflects on the concept of ‘mutuality’ in Chinese culture.
The mutualistic model of cooperation suggests that humans cooperate when benefits match or outweigh the costs.
I demonstrate that a deeper form of cooperation that impels people to cooperate despite a recognition of unfairness governs kinship in China (arguably also in other regions). The phenomenon is examined in relation to the ideology of harmony (hexie).
TO BE PUBLISHED
The Roar of Chinese Consumers: An Insider’s View
This book is a reflective analysis of the development of consumer society in China since it embarked on its tectonic reforms in the 1980s.
It shows how different actors, including government authorities, global and local industry players in the market, and consumers themselves, interacted to shape today’s market.
The book expands from two thematic ideas. The first is that the dramatic growth in the Chinese economy has led Chinese people to become happy citizens, but dissatisfied consumers. The second is that, despite the changes being driven by a highly centralised government, the increase in consumer spending has led to consumer citizens feeling more empowered. The acquisition of goods and services is a central feature of daily life and cultural identity. Individuals are encouraged to consume as a means of supporting economic growth, and consumption becomes a principal source of personal happiness.
I seek to provide the business community with an intimate glimpse into the complexities of Chinese consumers, supported by empirical evidence and academic rigor.
The book will interest everyone engaged in the China business, especially consumer marketing, and all informed readers who feel intellectually stimulated by the ever-evolving social and economic dynamics in China.
Chapters include:
The Power and Politics of Consumption
The Chinese Consumer Society: 1978-2024
There is No Best but Better
Luxury Purchase
Beauty Matters
The China Wave and Consumer Nationalism
Sustainability and Green Consumption
Digital-first Consumer Market